San Francisco 49ers Alternate Logo

Colton McKivitz

Colton McKivitz Player Profile

Summary

Colton McKivitz is a versatile offensive lineman for the San Francisco 49ers, originally drafted in the 5th round (153rd overall) of the 2020 NFL Draft out of the West Virginia Mountaineers. Bleacher ReportAt 6-foot-6 and around 301 pounds, he has developed from a swing tackle/guard prospect into a starting right tackle, showing a mix of technical improvement and scheme fit advancement. While still not perfect, his recent surge in pass-blocking efficiency has garnered praise and suggests his value has risen significantly. Niners Nation

Strengths

  • Versatility & experience at multiple line spots: McKivitz started 47 times in college at both left and right tackle, giving him experience and flexibility as a swing lineman in Year 1 and beyond. Bleacher Report

  • Competitive toughness & run-blocking prowess: Scouting reports cited that he “plays with a coveted mean-streak,” showing a willingness to finish blocks and sustain physical position. CBS Sports PFF grades show his run-blocking is elite among tackles: e.g., 80.1 run-block grade (6th of 77) as of recent metrics. PFF

  • Recent improvement in pass protection: After earlier struggles, McKivitz’s pass-blocking efficiency has improved markedly. In early 2025 he ranked among the best tackles (despite being a right tackle) in pass-block grade and pressure allowed. Niners Nation

Weaknesses

  • Anchoring against power & limited lateral flexibility: Early draft reports noted that he “struggles to anchor versus power and can get put on skates too often,” and that his hip flexibility and lateral movement were less than ideal. Bleacher Report

  • Inconsistent pass-protection earlier in career / questioned technique: Coaching staff have stated he “has some work to do” to solidify the right-tackle position, particularly after allowing multiple sacks the prior season. SI

  • Still building consistency under full starter workload: While his recent metrics are strong, some prior analyses (e.g., outlier games with high pressures allowed) suggest his ceiling is solid but his floor has been variable. Reddit

Fit & Outlook

McKivitz’s trajectory is upward: from a mid-round tackle pick with swing possibility to a bona fide starting right tackle, his recent performance suggests he’s closing in on his potential. If he continues to improve his pass-pro technique and sustain his run-blocking excellence, he could become a key anchor on the 49ers’ offensive line for years.