Summary

Shemar Stewart was selected in Round 1 (#17 Overall) of the 2025 NFL Draft out of Texas A&M University. Stewart entered college as a former five-star recruit and quickly became one of the most physically imposing defenders in the SEC. Across his collegiate career, he has recorded 90+ total tackles, 15+ tackles for loss, and multiple sacks and pressures, often impacting games beyond the box score due to his disruption and physical presence. Stewart is widely regarded as a traits-based, high-upside edge defender, boasting rare size, explosiveness, and length. Stewart raised some eyebrows as a rookie when he refused to participate in preseason activities due to a contract impasse, causing some to question his love for the game and dedication to success over money.

Strengths

• Unicorn Size-Athleticism Profile: Perfect 25.00 Athletic Score. His blend of length, mass, and movement skills are off the charts freaky.

• Explosive First Step: Flashes sudden get-off that stresses tackles early. Long arms allow him to disengage and disrupt passing lanes.

• Power at Point of Attack: Can collapse edges and walk tackles back with strength. Can align as a 4-3 DE or reduce inside on passing downs.

• Run Defense Presence: Sets firm edges and is difficult to move off his spot.

Weaknesses

• Pass-Rush Refinement: Still developing a consistent counter-move package. Mostly relies on athleticism rather than sequencing moves.

• Production vs. Traits Gap: Sack totals do not yet match physical ability, either in college or in the pros. Learning how to augment his finishing consistency.

• Pad Level Consistency: Can play too upright, limiting leverage.

• Processing Speed: Can be late reacting to misdirection and option looks. Needs continued reps to reach full potential.

Outlook

Stewart projects well into a physical, power-based defensive front like Cincinnati’s, where edge defenders are asked to set the edge, collapse pockets, and disrupt quarterbacks with length and force. He fits best as a base defensive end with the ability to kick inside on passing downs, allowing his size and explosiveness to stress guards. Early in his career, he would benefit from a rotational role while refining hand usage, rush sequencing, and leverage. Looking ahead, Stewart profiles as a Day 1–Day 2 NFL Draft prospect with starter-level upside. His floor is tied to run defense and physical disruption, while his ceiling depends on pass-rush development. If coaching unlocks his technique to match his traits, Stewart has the potential to become a high-impact edge defender capable of anchoring a defensive line. His combination of size, athleticism, and character makes him a high-upside investment for teams seeking long-term edge solutions.